I’m a little embarrassed admitting I enjoy positive
feedback. Sometimes I’m embarrassed – ashamed, even – that I need it. I’m a grown-up! Why do I need someone telling
me my writing is good? Why do I want someone to tell me it’s good enough? I
should be able to provide positive reinforcement for myself! It’s juvenile,
immature – childish, even – to want someone telling you you’re fabulous, or (gasp!)
that they love you and your work!
Unfortunately, I’m not at the stage of such enlightenment
that I don’t give a flying fig what anyone thinks of me. I do care. I’d totally
fail at being a good Buddhist.
Probably most of
us actually care what others think and want our work to be loved by all.
So, my heart was pounding yesterday when I read through the
email attachment with my professional critique from a US literary agent for the
children’s picture book I completed.
She had good feedback.
Suggested a couple
very easy fixes like sticking to “he said, she said” instead of adding words to
replace “said." Like when I wrote “sneered, Tommy.” Changing “sneered” to “said”
is fine. I’m not married to the word “sneered.” It’s not a poem.
The last sentence of the critique said she didn’t think the
story had a “saleable hook.” It was a
swallow pride moment. Scratch that. It was a swallow pride day.
I had been (foolishly?) optimistic and eager to get this
particular critique. Earlier, I had paid a children’s book author to critique
the same manuscript. Her critique was very positive and said the story was “delightful”
and what editors look for.
I felt proud when I heard the author's feedback. I felt proud of the
manuscript. I had worked very hard and enjoyed every minute of it. The positive
critique felt validating in some way, like “Yes! You can write. You can do
this!”
That’s not how I felt yesterday.
I really had to
struggle with those little – or not so little – voices in my head telling me, “I told you so. What do you think you’re
doing? You’re not cut out for this! Just quit while you’re ahead. Your writing
is nothing special and that story is dumb. All
your story ideas are lame and your writing is flimsy. You need to do something
different. I don’t know what you need to do, but it’s not
writing!”
I wrote
in this post how I’m just learning to
be courageous in my dreams and pursuing what is in my heart. I’m at this little
tender, vulnerable, fledgling stage.
In the past, I would’ve listened, and listened hard,
to those nasty critical voices in my head.
The truth is, in the past, yesterday’s news was enough to make me give
up writing my story. I would’ve stopped editing. I would not have submitted it.
And this wasn’t even a QUERY or a submission to an
agent. It was a critique I PAID for. I
ASKED for it! But I promise you this: I would’ve given up, dream shattered into
ten million pieces. No lie.
But I didn’t do that. I told myself I’m not going to give up.
In fact, I made myself …yes MADE myself…sit down and write yesterday. I didn’t
want to.
What I REALLY wanted was a gigantic Halloween sized bag of candy for trick-or-treaters. I really wanted to eat bags of KitKats
and Rollos and Reeses Peanut Butter Cups. Luckily, I can’t buy anything like
that in Yangon, which is a very good thing. (Right?)
Thing is, I was pissed off at writing, like writing was a
person who had bitten me. Had hurt me and betrayed me. Writing was NOT what I wanted to do.
But I did. I wrote. I didn’t write much. But I
wrote enough to make me come to my senses and realize an action, like writing, did not hurt me or my
little fragile ego. Writing is my
lifeline. Why the hell would I try to cut that line now?
Look, I know the children’s picture book market is extremely
competitive. I paid the agent to give me a critique. She did.
I also know this isn’t like a big rejection in some ways
because I have NOT submitted to agents or editors. I’ve only asked for it to be
professionally critiqued by two people and critiqued by dozens of friends. LOL
I got what I asked for.
I will edit this story and take on board her advice with the
other two children’s stories I’m working on.
Would I really like to be published? No. I would really love
to be published. That just means more hard work. And writing query letters. And
being brave enough to actually send my manuscript to an agent. For submission.
Not critique.
And that is what I’m going to do.
For the first time in
many years, I’m
not giving up.